Winners are bolded.
Best Lead Actress
- Kay Arnold for Hotel Frankenstein
- Chelsea Pyle for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Jerusha Renstrom for Yours or Mine
- Beka Osmond for Best Christmas Pageant Ever
- Alyssa Christensen for The Importance of Being Earnest
Best Lead Actor
- Mike Renstrom for Yours or Mine
- Nikki Pino for Jakes Corner
- Eric Raemakers for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Andrew Whittaker for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Tyler Renstrom for Cruise of Love II
- Joseph Smith for Detour to Pittsburgh
Best Supporting Actress
- Dana Anquoe for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Leslie Stott for Cruise of Love II
- Cara Baker for Hotel Frankenstein
- Aubrie Orrock for Hotel Frankenstein
- Sherrie Webb for Yours or Mine
- Cindy Bartell for Yours or Mine
Best Supporting Actor
- Jeff Scofield for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Keith Renstrom Jr. for Cruise of Love II
- Matt Bramwell for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Tyler Renstrom for Yours or Mine
- Chad Conrad for Yours or Mine
- Keith Renstrom Jr. for Jakes Corner
Best Character Actress
- Leslie Stott for Hotel Frankenstein
- Alexis Pino for Hotel Frankenstein
- Jana Nate for Hotel Frankenstein
- Sherrie Webb for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Kristen Dollie Leinbacher for Shadowbrook Mansion
Best Character Actor
- Mike Black for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Tyler Renstrom for Hotel Frankenstein
- Zach Chapman for Hotel Frankenstein
Best Cameo Actress
- Marilyn Davis for Cruise of Love II
- Barbara Higinbotham for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- M’liss Tolman for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Katrina Tucker for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
Best Cameo Actor
- Kevin Tucker for Cruise of Love II
- Tyrone Svedin for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Bob Grant for Hotel Frankenstein
- Kevin Tucker for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
Best Senior Actress
- Susan Cosney for Time After Time
- Marlene Arnold for Shadowbrook Mansion
- Marlene Arnold for Cruise of Love II
Best Senior Actor
- Ray Felix for Yours or Mine
- Ken Norris for Shadowbrook Mansion
- Don Cosney for Time After Time
- Ernie Bramwell for Hotel Frankenstein
Best Youth Actress
- Mikayla Westover for Jake’s Corner
- Monica Smith for Cruise of Love II
- Maddie Renstrom for Time After Time
Best Youth Actor
- Josh Taylor for Jakes Corner
- Braydon Giles for Time After Time
- Daniel Blackman for Yours or Mine
- Josh Wright for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- Alex Day for Yours or Mine
- Drey Means for Time After Time
Best Youth Character Actress
- Katie Chevrier for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Susannah Osmond for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Stefanie Luna for Time After Time
Best Child Actress
- Tessa Conrad for Yours or Mine
- Keely Conrad for Yours or Mine
- Sarah Osmond for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Tiana Westover for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
Best Child Actor
- McRae Morgan for Hotel Frankenstein
- Daniel Gregson for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Matthew Higinbotham for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- Cayden Clark for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Colby Conrad for Yours or Mine
- Nate Day for Yours or Mine
Best Child Character Actress
- Rachel Higinbotham for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- Amaura Renstrom for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Whitney Kingsolver for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
Best Costumes
- Jody Renstrom, Dana Anquoe, and Felicia Thorpe for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Felicia thorpe, Jennifer Blackman, and Dana Stubbs for Cruise of Love II
- Jody Renstrom for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Jody Renstrom for Yours or Mine
Best Lights and Sound
- M’liss Tollman and Tyrone Svedin for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Sydnee Hill and Shaylee Kofford for Shadowbrook Mansion
- Stephen Johnson for Time After Time
- Ernie Bramwell for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Ian Fugal for Hotel Frankenstein
Best Director
- Mike Black for Hotel Frankenstein
- Julie Doud for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Beka Osmond for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Dana Stubbs for Cruise of Love II
Best Play of 2011
- Yours or Mine, Cast A
- The Importance of Being Earnest
- Hotel Frankenstein
- Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
