Winners are bolded.
Best Lead Actress
- Kay Arnold for Hotel Frankenstein
- Chelsea Pyle for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Jerusha Renstrom for Yours or Mine
- Beka Osmond for Best Christmas Pageant Ever
- Alyssa Christensen for The Importance of Being Earnest
Best Lead Actor
- Mike Renstrom for Yours or Mine
- Nikki Pino for Jakes Corner
- Eric Raemakers for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Andrew Whittaker for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Tyler Renstrom for Cruise of Love II
- Joseph Smith for Detour to Pittsburgh
Best Supporting Actress
- Dana Anquoe for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Leslie Stott for Cruise of Love II
- Cara Baker for Hotel Frankenstein
- Aubrie Orrock for Hotel Frankenstein
- Sherrie Webb for Yours or Mine
- Cindy Bartell for Yours or Mine
Best Supporting Actor
- Jeff Scofield for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Keith Renstrom Jr. for Cruise of Love II
- Matt Bramwell for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Tyler Renstrom for Yours or Mine
- Chad Conrad for Yours or Mine
- Keith Renstrom Jr. for Jakes Corner
Best Character Actress
- Leslie Stott for Hotel Frankenstein
- Alexis Pino for Hotel Frankenstein
- Jana Nate for Hotel Frankenstein
- Sherrie Webb for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Kristen Dollie Leinbacher for Shadowbrook Mansion
Best Character Actor
- Mike Black for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Tyler Renstrom for Hotel Frankenstein
- Zach Chapman for Hotel Frankenstein
Best Cameo Actress
- Marilyn Davis for Cruise of Love II
- Barbara Higinbotham for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- M’liss Tolman for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Katrina Tucker for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
Best Cameo Actor
- Kevin Tucker for Cruise of Love II
- Tyrone Svedin for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Bob Grant for Hotel Frankenstein
- Kevin Tucker for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
Best Senior Actress
- Susan Cosney for Time After Time
- Marlene Arnold for Shadowbrook Mansion
- Marlene Arnold for Cruise of Love II
Best Senior Actor
- Ray Felix for Yours or Mine
- Ken Norris for Shadowbrook Mansion
- Don Cosney for Time After Time
- Ernie Bramwell for Hotel Frankenstein
Best Youth Actress
- Mikayla Westover for Jake’s Corner
- Monica Smith for Cruise of Love II
- Maddie Renstrom for Time After Time
Best Youth Actor
- Josh Taylor for Jakes Corner
- Braydon Giles for Time After Time
- Daniel Blackman for Yours or Mine
- Josh Wright for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- Alex Day for Yours or Mine
- Drey Means for Time After Time
Best Youth Character Actress
- Katie Chevrier for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Susannah Osmond for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Stefanie Luna for Time After Time
Best Child Actress
- Tessa Conrad for Yours or Mine
- Keely Conrad for Yours or Mine
- Sarah Osmond for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Tiana Westover for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
Best Child Actor
- McRae Morgan for Hotel Frankenstein
- Daniel Gregson for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Matthew Higinbotham for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- Cayden Clark for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Colby Conrad for Yours or Mine
- Nate Day for Yours or Mine
Best Child Character Actress
- Rachel Higinbotham for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- Amaura Renstrom for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Whitney Kingsolver for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
Best Costumes
- Jody Renstrom, Dana Anquoe, and Felicia Thorpe for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Felicia thorpe, Jennifer Blackman, and Dana Stubbs for Cruise of Love II
- Jody Renstrom for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Jody Renstrom for Yours or Mine
Best Lights and Sound
- M’liss Tollman and Tyrone Svedin for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Sydnee Hill and Shaylee Kofford for Shadowbrook Mansion
- Stephen Johnson for Time After Time
- Ernie Bramwell for Detour to Pittsburgh
- Ian Fugal for Hotel Frankenstein
Best Director
- Mike Black for Hotel Frankenstein
- Julie Doud for The Importance of Being Earnest
- Beka Osmond for Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B
- Dana Stubbs for Cruise of Love II
Best Play of 2011
- Yours or Mine, Cast A
- The Importance of Being Earnest
- Hotel Frankenstein
- Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast A
- Best Christmas Pageant Ever, Cast B






{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }
Either my getting a trophy was a mistake, or there is a mistake with the bolding for Best Female actress… Lol… I think it might be the opposite for that award. (-:
Alyssa, sorry if there was a mistake. I didn’t attend the ceremony.
Are you talking about the Best Lead Actress category? If so, who were the real winners? It seemed like there were dual winners in almost every category. LOL